Caption Contest No. 40

Winning Submission:

"Welcome to Fantasy Island"

Honorable Mentions
"Dad?"
"Say fromage!"
"With blood on our hands"
"What happens in Vegas..."
"Menudo's Christmas Reunion Special"
"On Prancer and Prancer and Prancer and Prancer"
"All the other reindeer used to laugh and call them names."
"I sure hope this picture doesn't end up in some caption contest."
"Santa was shocked when he found four of his reindeer on the Naughty List."
"Lance, I said no see thru nipple shirts! What part of that didn't you understand?"
"Rejected album art from the long-lost Emo Diaries No. 74: Me Against the Reindeer"